Skip to main content
A Cobra in the Forest? Quantifying the Impact of Perverse Incentives from Indonesia's Deforestation Moratorium, 2011 to 2016
Project Start Date
05/01/2018
Project End Date
05/01/2021
Project Call Name
Regional_Initiative_Name
Solicitation
default

Team Members:

Person Name Person role on project Affiliation
Matthew Hansen Principal Investigator University of Maryland, College Park, College Park, United States
Julie Silva Co-Investigator University of Maryland, College Park, College Park, US
Peter Potapov Co-Investigator University of Maryland, College Park, USA
Ahmad Maryudi Collaborator
Arief Wijaya Collaborator
Abstract

While initially heralded as a win for conservation and sustainable forest management, the Indonesian government’s moratorium halting the issuance of new licenses for logging, palm oil, and wood-fiber plantations in primary natural forests and peatlands has not substantially slowed deforestation. In fact the highest area of primary forest clearing since 2000 occurred in 2012, the first year of the moratorium’s implementation. Compared to Brazil, whose forest policy and associated enforcement has reduced deforestation by over 70%, Indonesia has made little or no progress in slowing primary forest loss. The acceleration of forest conversion in Indonesia suggests the government’s moratorium resulted in a Cobra Effect, whereby the policy created perverse incentives for local actors and industries to acquire permits prior to the freeze and intensify forest land conversion in the aftermath. The proposed study integrates remote sensing, socioeconomic analysis, and spatially explicit modeling to address the following research questions: 1) To what extent can accelerated forest clearing be attributed to perverse incentives driven by Indonesia’s moratorium, 2) What political mechanisms enabled this policy to produce these unintended effects, and 3) How do socio-economic livelihoods and well-being vary across areas with different post-moratorium outcomes?

Project Research Area

Project Documents

Year Authors Type Title
2019 Julie Silva NASA LCLUC Science Team Presentation Quantifying Corruption in Indonesian Land System Governance